Pros and Cons of 2 Check Valves Types

Author: Liang

Sep. 09, 2024

Pros and Cons of 2 Check Valves Types

One of the most essential valves in water and wastewater pumping systems is the check valve. Its purpose is to automatically open while pumps are running, and return to the closed position to prevent reverse flow when the pumps are not in operation. These valves help minimize energy consumption and protect the pumping system from pressure surges and damage from reverse flow.

Click here to get more.

Selecting check valves for a process is like selecting hardware for new cabinets. Once you decide on a knob or a handle, there's a multitude of styles, colors, and price points to consider beyond that. Same with check valves. It's pretty clear the process you're working on requires a check valve, but which one? Each style of check valve is designed to meet a certain need. Here's the pros and cons of two different styles of check valves, the lift check and swing check.

Lift Check Valves

Lift check valves are commonly used in high-rise buildings, industrial and power plant applications, and water and wastewater applications. They have no external moving parts and are known to be economical and reliable. Over time, these types of valves can have high energy costs because the disc remains in the flow stream during operation.

Silent Check Valve

Silent check valves are known for their quiet closure. Flow pushes the disc to allow forward flow. When the pump is stopped, a compression spring pushes the disc into the seat before flow reverses, hence the silent closure.

This type of check valve is most commonly used in clean water applications with high head.

Nozzle check valves are very similar to the silent check valve, are meant for high pressure, industrial and power applications.

Ball Check Valve

Ball check valves are commonly used in water and wastewater applications. They have very simple operation, and are compact and economical too. These valves feature a rubber coated ball that moves in and out of the seat as flow moves forward and reverse.

Because the ball has a long way to travel when the pump shuts off, these valves have a high tendency to slam in high head applications.

Swing Check Valves

Swing checks are certainly some of the most common check valves used in water and wastewater pumping systems. They're readily available and relatively low cost. They're also automatic, requiring no external power source, guided only by the direction of flow.

These valves can come in a few different configurations, operating in the same basic way.

Dual-Disc

This check valve features a wafer body design and two D-shaped discs that rotate out of the way as flow enters the valve. It has good non-slam characteristics, but is not recommended for wastewater applications. It is also susceptible to vibration and wear.

Traditional Swing Check

Everyone knows this one, right? It's definitely the most common check valve in water and wastewater applications. This type of valve usually has metal or resilient seats and a 60-90 degree swing. This valve has a tendency to slam, however, due to the long stroke, friction in the packing, and inertia of the disc.

Air cushions are sometimes employed to help alleviate the slamming. Though some believe that a lever and spring is a better accessory as they allow the valve to close faster.

Tilted Disc Check Valve

The difference between the tilted disc check valve and the traditional swing check valve is that flow is allowed to pass on both sides of the disc. Because of this, it allows for extremely low head loss.

This valve is not recommended for wastewater applications because pins that extend into flow stream tend to collect debris. Clean water or treated effluent are best for this valve.

Do you have the right type of check valve for your application? Could there be a better one? Always discuss changes to your pumping system with an engineer who is well versed in all types of check valves. They may be able to help you find a valve that slams less or could even be more energy efficient.

Not sure if you should change up your check valves? Ask us about it! We gladly provide technical assistance to businesses and municipalities in Wisconsin, Minnesota, Illinois, and upper Michigan.

 

Check Valve: What is it? How Does It Work, Types Of

Check Valves

Please fill out the following form to submit a Request for Quote to any of the following companies listed on



Introduction

Here is the most complete guide on the internet to check valves.

You will learn about:

  • What is a Check Valve?
  • Types of Check Valves
  • How are Check Valves Used?
  • How Does a Check Valve Work?
  • And much more &#;

Chapter One &#; What is a Check Valve?

A check valve is an automatic safety device designed to permit fluids and gases to flow in one direction while preventing reverse flow. When pressure is applied, fluids enter the valve through the inlet, pushing the disc off the valve seat and allowing the fluid to exit through the outlet.

Flow remains steady as long as the pressure is sufficient to keep the disc open. When the pressure drops, the disc automatically returns to its seat, shutting off the flow.

The pressure required to open the valve is known as the cracking pressure, which can range from 3 psi to 350 psi depending on the size, purpose, and function of the check valve.

Check valves ensure that gases or liquids flow in the correct direction and create tight seals to prevent leaks. By regulating the flow of liquids, check valves help protect pumps and compressors from significant damage.


Check valves are known by various names depending on their use and design. Common names include clack, non-return (NRV), reflux, retention, and one-way valves. Despite their simple design and function, these valves are crucial for protecting pumps, piping systems, and fluid flow.

The swing check valve, shown in the image below, is the most common type. It features a full port design, allowing the disc to be completely out of the way during fluid flow. The disc opens with the direction of the flow and remains open while the flow continues. When the flow slows or stops, the disc moves back into the closed position due to gravity.

The primary function of a check valve is to prevent reverse flow, which can damage pumps and other mechanisms. When a check valve closes, it can cause water hammer, where the fluid in the system slams against the closed valve. This necessitates that check valves be resilient, durable, and constructed from high-quality materials to withstand such impacts.

Check valves can generate noise and may require noise suppression. To address this, various control mechanisms are incorporated into their design. Springs, levers, or weights are used to manage surges and prevent the valve from slamming shut.


Chapter Two &#; What Are The Different Types of Check Valves

Check valves come in numerous varieties to suit various applications. They are used in both industrial and commercial settings. In gardening, check valves regulate the flow of fertilizers and water in irrigation systems. In the aerospace and aircraft industries, they control corrosive fluids, hydraulic systems, and fuel flow.

While the primary function of check valves remains consistent across applications, the types of check valves vary based on factors such as flow rate, media gravity and temperature, line size, pressure, and flow velocity, as illustrated in the chart below.

Application of Check Valves Type Flow Media Type Velocity Range FPS(m/s) Recommended Check Valve Uniform With Insignificant Reversal Water Or Oil 1 to 6 (0.3 to 2) Swing Check w/ Lever and ctrl wt. Steam, Water, Gas 7 to 100 (2 to 30) Simple Swing Uniform Water Or Oil 5 to 10 Max (a.5 to 3) In-line Guided Disc Pulsating Air Or Gas 5 to 10 Max (a.5 to 3) In-line Guided Disc w/Cushion Chamber Uniform With Normal Reversal Water Or Oil 7 to 10 (2 to 3) Swing w/ Spring Assist To Close Uniform With Severe Reversal Water Or Oil 7 to 10 (2 to 3) Swing w/ Dashpot Uniform Or Pulsating Steam, Water, Or Gas 8 to 160 (2.5 to 50) Tee- Or Inclined- Pattern Lift Uniform Or Pulsating (Severe Revesal) Steam, Water, Or Gas 10 to 160 (3 to 50) Tee- Pattern Lift w/ Dashpot Uniform Steam, Water, Or Gas 12 to 250 (4 to 75) Tilting Disc Uniform Or Pulsating Steam, Water, Or Gas Or Oil 20 to 250 (6 to 75) Wye-Pattern Lift Uniform Or Pulsating (Severe Revesal)     Wye-Pattern Lift w/ dashpot

Check Valve Types

Selecting the appropriate check valve requires careful consideration of the application's specific needs. Engineers must choose a valve that matches the type of media, pipe size, pressure gradient, fluid velocity, and pumping mechanism. Evaluating these factors is essential to ensure safe operation and to protect equipment.

Check valves come in a broad range, from standard models available at home improvement stores to custom designs tailored for specific applications. Given the constant development of new check valves, it's challenging to provide a comprehensive list. However, despite their variety, all check valves share certain common descriptive factors.

Swing Check Valves

A swing check valve is a self-activating valve designed to prevent backflow or allow flow in only one direction. It features a disc that pivots on a hinge away from the valve seat to permit forward flow. When the flow ceases, the disc swings back into position to block reverse flow. The disc must be heavy enough to resist the impact of the return flow. Swing check valves are known for minimizing turbulence and having a low pressure drop.

Lever and weight swing check valves are ideal for situations where water hammer might occur, while those with lever and spring mechanisms are suited for high-pressure and high-flow velocity applications. Regardless of the type, it is essential to regularly inspect and clean the disc of swing check valves.


Wafer Check Valves

Wafer check valves feature a slim disc that swings to regulate flow. When the media flows in the intended direction, it lifts the disc off its seat. If the flow reverses, the disc moves back to seal the valve and prevent backflow. Often, a spring or lever is incorporated to ensure quicker closing and to help minimize water hammer.

The thin, short, and compact design of wafer check valves makes them ideal for small pipe systems and systems that move solid or semi solid media.


Tilting Disc Check Valve

A tilting disc check valve features a disc that pivots at its center, allowing fluid to flow over both the top and bottom of the disc. This design is particularly useful in applications with frequent flow reversals. Unlike a swing check valve, where the flow velocity keeps the disc open, a tilting disc valve relies on the flow to maintain the open position. The disc is small and lightweight, with its center of gravity near the pivot point. This valve exhibits a low pressure drop at low flow rates but experiences a higher pressure drop at high flow rates.


Ball Check Valves

Ball check valves use a ball that moves up and down in the valve to block the flow. The seat of the valve is designed to fit the ball and has a conically shaped chamber that guides the ball to the seat. The weight of the ball can vary depending on the pump capacity and the possibility of water hammer.

When reverse flow occurs, the ball returns to its seat, sealing off the flow. With sufficient pressure, the ball is lifted away from the seat. As the pressure decreases, the ball drops back down and is guided to its seat to block the flow.

Link to Yaxing Valve

Featured content:
How Does Wireline Pressure Control Equipment Work?

Butterfly Valves

A butterfly check valve is also known as a dual, folding disc, double disc, or splits check valve. The halves of the disc open toward the centerline, as seen in the diagram, during the forward flow of the fluid. With reverse flow, the halves open and seal the pipe. The short distance that the halves have to travel lessens the slamming effect on the discs. Butterfly check valves operate very quietly making them ideal for heating, ventilation, and air conditioning systems.


Lift Check Valves

The flow for lift check valves enters below the seat of the valve. The pressure of the flow lifts the disc or ball off the seat. When the flow weakens, slows, reverses, or stops, gravity forces the disc or ball downward onto the seat. They are ideal for systems with high flow and velocity rates.


Silent Check Valves

Silent check valves, or poppet check valves, prevent water hammer or shock by closing before fluid flow can reverse. They close quickly and smoothly, reducing the risk of damage to surrounding materials.


Duckbill Check Valves

Duckbill check valves are made of rubber or synthetic elastomer and have the shape of a duck&#;s beak. The open end of the valve is stretched over the outlet to the supply line. The other end retains its normal shape. Upstream pressure forces the duckbill lips open allowing the flow. As the pressure increases, the lips open wider. As the pressure gets lower, the lips return to a flatten and close.


Diaphragm Check Valves

Diaphragm check valves feature a rubber diaphragm or disc that seals the valve. The valve is centered in the seating area, with the sealing surface on the inlet side and an opening in the center. When backflow occurs, the rubber disc covers the sealing opening, effectively closing it to prevent reverse flow.


Foot Check Valves

A foot check valve is installed at the bottom of a pipe connected to a pump. It functions similarly to a ball check valve but includes a screen to block debris. The valve's opening is larger than that of the pipe. Foot valves help maintain the pump&#;s prime. During operation, suction from the pump pulls water up through the pipe and foot valve. When the pump is turned off, gravity causes the water in the pipe to flow back. The foot check valve prevents this by blocking the water's path and is held closed by the weight of the water.


Pneumatic Check Valves

Pneumatic check valves, also known as air check valves, regulate the flow of air from a compressor by allowing air to enter but preventing it from escaping. They are used in pneumatic circuits where airflow needs to be controlled in a single direction.


Leading Manufacturers and Suppliers

    Chapter Three &#; How are Check Valves Used

    Since the invention of the self-sealing valve in the early 20th century, check valves have become essential for addressing backflow issues across various industries. Any sector involved in transporting products through pipelines relies on check valves within their systems.

    Check valves are cost-effective devices that help prevent waste and protect equipment. They ensure that fluids traveling through piping networks are not lost due to poor handling. By automatically stopping liquid flow when pressure drops or flow decreases, check valves block backflow and retain the fluid within the system.

    Check Valve Uses

    Pumps

    Check valves in pumps is one of their more common uses.

    • Single Pump System &#; The check valve controls a flow from a suction tank and blocks it from reversing when the pump stops.
    • Parallel Pump System &#; In a parallel pump system, a check valve prevents the duty pump from pumping into the standby pump.


    • Series Pump System &#; A series of pumps is used when pumping materials in a pipe line over long distances. If any of the pumps fail in the series, the check valve activates to prevent losses.
    • Pressure Relief &#; Spring loaded check valves are used in gas applications for low pressure conditions. If the pressure in the system rises above the cracking pressure, the check valve safely releases the gas.


    • Foot Valve &#; The foot valve blocks debris and prevents water from returning to the well when the pump is turned off.

    Pharmaceutical

    In the pharmaceutical industry, check valves are essential for fluid movement, as they regulate pressure to ensure product quality, efficiency, and production. Only sanitary check valves are suitable for this application, as they must be easily cleanable without disassembly and feature silent closing with a tight seal.


    Aircraft Hydraulic Systems

    Orifice check valves are employed in the hydraulic systems of landing gear actuators. During gear retraction, fluid flows to raise the gear. When extending the gear, the check valve regulates the flow out of the actuator to prevent uncontrolled dropping. In addition to landing gear systems, check valves are also used in aircraft hydraulic, fuel, and pneumatic systems.


    Irrigation Systems

    In an irrigation system, check valves are positioned near the source to prevent backflow and siphoning of irrigation water, ensuring that water does not flow back into the source.

    Fuel Pump

    Check valves are found in vehicles that were made before the invention of the electronic injection system. Old car fuel pumps have a check valve located at the pump&#;s inlet and one at the outlet, They are designed to force the fuel to flow in the correct direction. When the check valve goes bad, the fuel pressure goes down.


    Water Supply Check Valves

    Water in a home should only move from the supply line and out through a fixture or from a drain to the sewer. Check valves are located in homes to prevent cross connection or backflow. They come in several varieties including ball and swing check valves. Domestic check valves can be seen below on a diagram of a hot water system for a home.


    Heating Boiler

    In heating boilers, check valves prevent hot water from circulating when the thermostat is not active. They stop water from returning to the boiler, which helps avoid excessive pressure buildup. Additionally, in a home heating system, a check valve ensures that boiler water does not flow into the domestic water supply, protecting it from contamination used for drinking, bathing, or cooking.


    Liquid Fuel

    Liquid fuel check valves are engineered to work with various fuels, including jet fuel, hydraulic oil, synthetic oil, and air. They are designed to ensure stable operation from the valve's initial crack to full flow. The valve features an inverted spool with an integrated pressure sensor to maintain balance and stability, keeping a consistent delta pressure within the valve. This design allows for smooth and uniform valve opening.

    Chapter Four &#; How Does a Check Valve Work?

    To understand how a check valve functions, it's crucial to first examine its construction. A basic check valve consists of four key components: the body, seat, disc, and cover, as illustrated in the diagram below.


    Depending on the design and function of the check valve, additional components such as springs, balls, stems, and hinge pins may be incorporated into the basic elements.

    How Various Types of Check Valves Work

    Swing

    Swing check valves feature an unguided disc that swings open fully when flow pressure is applied. They are available in various sizes and designs to suit different applications.


    Lift

    Lift check valves use a guided piston that rises when flow enters the valve. The seat has a barrel design and is secured with screws and seals. The valve's opening matches the size of both the inlet and outlet.


    Tilting

    Tilting check valves are designed to address some issues associated with swing check valves, which have been the most common type. They can stay open at low flow velocities and close swiftly when the flow stops. They are particularly effective in high-velocity applications.


    Folding Disk

    The folding disc check valve features a split disc design and a wafer body pattern with a soft seat. The discs are held in place by a pivot rod and open in response to the flow pressure. Springs on the discs assist in closing the valve.


    Vertical Check Valves

    Vertical check valves are also known as spring check valves A spring keeps the disc pressed against the seat in a vertical or spring check valve. The valve remains closed due to the spring until sufficient pressure is applied to compress the spring and open the valve. While the pressure is maintained, the valve stays open and the spring remains compressed. When the pressure drops, the spring pushes the disc back onto the seat, shutting off the flow. Vertical and spring check valves are known for their reliable backflow protection.


    Materials Used to Make Check Valves:

    Check valves are typically constructed from durable materials to endure high-pressure conditions. Common materials used in their manufacture include PVC, CPVC, bronze, brass, iron, and stainless steel.

    Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC): PVC is corrosion resistant and flexible. The smooth surface of PVC allows the check valve parts to move easily.

    Chlorinated Polyvinyl Chloride (CPVC): CPVC has the same qualities as PVC but is able to endure high temperature applications.

    Bronze: Bronze can be used for low and medium pressure applications, be cast in complex configurations, and is corrosion resistant.

    Brass: Brass has the same abilities as bronze as well as the same machinability and is less expensive than bronze.

    Cast Iron:Cast iron check valves are used for hot and cold water, HVAC, steam, gas, and utility services due to its excellent corrosion resistance.

    Ductile Iron:Ductile iron has more than 3% carbon so it can be bent and shaped easily. It is stronger than cast iron and is easier to form into check valves.

    Iron: Iron is used for steam, water, oil, and gas applications. It can endure a wide range of temperatures and pressures. Its excellent performance balances its high cost.

    Stainless Steel: Stainless steel is corrosion resistant, durable, and can be used in harsh conditions, including chemical applications.

    Polypropylene (PP):PP is used to make check valves due to its exceptional resistance to corrosion, which is superior to CPVC and PVC.

    Polyvinylidene Difluoride (PVDF):PVDF plastic is used in applications where exceptional purity and resistance to acids, solvents, and hydrocarbons are a necessity.

    Cast Steel:Cast steel is used to produce check valves due to its sudden impact resistance without deforming, breaking, or bending. It can also be easily shaped to any type of check valve.

    Chapter Five &#; What Are The Advantages and Disadvantages of Check Valves

    The major benefit of check valves is their ability to perform without having to be monitored or controlled. Their basic design allows them to be inserted into a pipe&#;s flow and be able to control the flow without being managed.

    Regardless of their many benefits, check valves are like any other type of mechanism and have drawbacks.

    Advantages of Check Valves

    1. Prevent backflow
    2. Able to endure high and low pressure conditions
    3. Perform as a backup and safety system
    4. Able to be used horizontally and vertically
    5. Self-actuated
    6. Fast acting.
    7. Protect pumps and compressors from damage caused by backflow
    8. Reduce downtime and loss of production
    9. Prevent water hammer
    10. Reduce sudden valve failure
    11. Lower maintenance costs
    12. Few moving parts
    13. Smaller footprint
    14. Able to cope with variable flow conditions
    15. Do not require power to operate

    Disadvantages of Check Valves

    1. Do not operate in pulsating systems
    2. Closing element can slam closed causing damage and wear
    3. Operate in a completely enclosed system
    4. Impossible to check if they are open or closed
    5. Internal parts cannot be checked
    6. Disks can get stuck in the open position.
    7. Noise from slamming discs
    8. Water hammer
    9. Reverse flow problems

    Common Problems with Check Valves

    Water Hammer

    Water hammer is caused by a pressure surge when there is a sudden stop in the flow of a gas or fluid and the valve suddenly closes, which causes noise and vibrations. Water hammer can damage the system and lead to costly repairs

    Water hammer can be mitigated by using check valves that close quickly, thereby preventing pressure surges and shock waves. Silent check valves are one effective solution to address this issue.

    Reverse Flow

    Reverse flow can be damaging and costly, as it may cause a pump to spin in the wrong direction. This issue can be addressed with tightly fitting, fast-closing check valves. Spring-assisted check valves, in particular, are beneficial because they react quickly to prevent reverse flow.

    Oversizing

    Some check valve systems experience chattering due to frequent opening and closing of the valve, often caused by an oversized valve. Proper sizing is crucial when installing a check valve to ensure it fits the application. The disc must remain stable when open and create a complete seal when closed to prevent issues like fluttering, repeated cycling, and potential valve failure.

    Installation

    Improper installation and assembly of a check valve can lead to future issues. The initial step is to select the appropriate check valve for the application, considering factors such as flow capacity, positioning, and orientation. Installing a check valve too close to a pump, for example, can result in turbulence and potential damage to the valve.

    Check valves should be installed at least several straight pipe diameters upstream from circulators, elbows, tees, and strainers to avoid turbulence and prevent the disc from rattling against the seat.

    Conclusion

    • Check valves are a method for controlling the flow of gases or liquids.
    • Check valves are cost saving devices that prevent waste and protect equipment.
    • Check valves vary according to the flow rate, media gravity and temperature, line size, pressure, and velocity of the flow, which can be seen in the chart below.
    • A basic check valve has four individual parts: body, seat, disc, and cover.
    • There are endless varieties of check valves to fit multiple applications.

    Leading Manufacturers and Suppliers

      Want more information on What are Check Valves? Feel free to contact us.

      60

      0

      Comments

      Please Join Us to post.

      0/2000

      All Comments ( 0 )

      Guest Posts

      If you are interested in sending in a Guest Blogger Submission,welcome to write for us!

      Your Name: (required)

      Your Email: (required)

      Subject:

      Your Message: (required)